During many of our demonstrations and community events, potential students are curious about the difference between Tai Chi and Yoga. Interesting question with no short answer. At this time, perhaps more so than in the past, people are looking for ways to relax, become more mindful, and to improve their mental and physical health. In fact, a recent article I read stated that for most people, “stress and anxiety have become ubiquitous companions”. This is may be why more people are turning to Tai Chi or Yoga. Both ancient mind-body exercises focus on physical and mental well-being. Both practices incorporate deep breathing, motion, and meditation to balance and harmonize the body and mind.
Tai Chi and Yoga have a lot of similarities, as well as unique differences, especially when you consider the many variations available. That being said, both (with some adaptations) are perfect for people of all ages, fitness levels, and abilities.
So how do you decide which is best for you?
While both practices focus on harmony of the mind and body, Tai Chi has its roots in Chinese martial arts. Yoga is more spiritual and originated in ancient India. As a first step, determine whether you are seeking stress relief, increased flexibility, spiritual growth, physical fitness, or something else entirely.
When choosing, you should consider your health, age, any disabilities and/or limitations you may have, and your fitness level. Obviously, at the beginner level, both practices are fairly easy. However, both disciplines have variations that can be quite demanding.
Your choice might come down to the availability of classes in your area or online. Can you learn from videos? Yes, however, posture and/or movement accuracy, and correct body alignment under the guidance of a qualified instructor can help you avoid injury. You also avoid bad habits which are much harder to correct later. Either way, both Tai Chi and Yoga are incredibly beneficial no matter what your age and/or level of fitness is.
Let’s look closer at Tai Chi and Yoga.
Tai Chi was initially developed for self-defense, and is an ancient Chinese martial art with “profound philosophical underpinnings”. There are those who continue to practice it as a martial art, however, it has evolved into a popular, serene, flowing, graceful form of exercise which focuses on integration of the mind, body, and spirit. The movements are designed to create, store, and foster the flow of Qi (life or vital energy) in the body. Correct body alignment is emphasized and “Forms” align with the Tai Chi principles. When a practitioner achieves internal and external harmony, Tai Chi becomes a meditative (and holistic) well-being journey.
Yoga, originated in ancient India thousands of years ago, as both a physical exercise and a spiritual discipline. Its focus is on uniting the body, mind, and spirit. Yoga’s goal is the achievement of balance and inner peace.
Both practices improve cardiac function, circulation, and body awareness. Tai Chi and Yoga both teach, and rely on, correct body alignment. As I mentioned earlier, practitioners achieve mindfulness and relaxation by incorporating deep breathing techniques and meditation. Each practice or style can range from gentle to demanding, and many different, unique forms exist. Both Tai Chi and Yoga improve strength and balance, can be tailored to the individual, and reduce stress and anxiety. It is the approach that differs.
Understanding some of the differences may help you chose the one that best fits your goals and preferences.
Tai Chi is an excellent choice for those who like a flowing exercise that is gentle on the body. Even though it is considered a “soft martial art” (meaning internal), Tai Chi is most frequently practiced in the west for exercise, stress management, mindfulness, and balance. A series of slow, gentle movements flow from one position to another to enhance and improve the flow of Qi (life/vital energy) in the body. Movement patterns are circular and muscles and core are strengthened without harsh body impact. Core balance, strength, mind-body connection, and flexibility are attained. The health and proprioception of the Tai Chi practitioner is improved and the risks of falls decreases.
Besides enhancing coordination, calmness, and clarity, Tai Chi helps improve mental well-being. The emphasis is on relaxation, maintaining smooth transitions, and cultivating internal strength.
Because Tai Chi is adaptable to different physical and mental limitations, as well as fitness levels, it is a popular choice among those with disabilities and older adults. In fact, some forms can be done sitting and/or lying down.
Yoga involves holding several different poses for longer periods. The focus is on stretching and strengthening the muscles with the aim of uniting the body, mind, and spirit. It is said to promote holistic well-being, flexibility, and core strength. Yoga can be restorative and modified with “props and adjustments” to meet individual needs.
Yoga strengthens muscles through poses that tone and stretch the body. Yoga emphasizes holding poses and aligning the body correctly to achieve physical and mental benefits.
What about spiritual and/or religious aspects?
Tai Chi is based on Taoist principles and the principles of Yin and Yang. The focus is cultivating, balancing, and storing life energy (Qi). Continuous flowing, circular movements prevent Qi stagnation, deficiency, or blockages, which are believed to cause illness and disease. Tai Chi has less emphasis on spiritual elements.
Yoga has its roots in ancient Indian philosophy. Its focus is achieving a union (Yoga) between the mind, body, and spirit. It does this through postures, breath, and meditation. Yoga has spiritual and philosophical components.
What about risks?
Tai Chi is relatively risk-free and good body alignment and adherence to the Tai Chi principles are vital to keep it that way. If you have joint or balance issues, or would just prefer a gentle practice, Tai Chi may be a better fit than Yoga. However, if you have a health issue, be sure to check with your health care provider. Practitioners should always stay within their comfort zone. This is not “no pain, no gain”. It’s “no pain, no pain”. No movement should cause you pain. If it does, tell your instructor immediately.
Yoga is also safe, however, some poses may pose a risk for individuals, especially those with health problems as well as beginners. Incorrect alignment, overstretching, and pushing oneself can injure your back, knees, shoulders, and other joints. This is where a qualified instructor is very important.
Where does one find classes?
Tai Chi classes can be found in dedicated schools or groups, community centers, community education, clubs, outdoors, etc.
Yoga is usually practiced indoors but may be found in some outdoor settings, studios, schools, gyms, dedicated schools, etc.
Bottom line: Both Tai Chi and yoga are ancient practices which offer a myriad of mind-body benefits. The choice comes down to an individual’s preferences, goals, age, physical condition, and interests. No choice is final. If interested, you may decide to explore both to see which one is a good fit for you. I have many students who do both Tai Chi and Yoga. Just be sure to find a qualified instructor that you feel comfortable with.
There are overwhelming benefits to be derived from either practice. Remember: regular/consistent practice is crucial in order to achieve the “promised” benefits.
I wish you well on your journey towards health and peace.
Subscribe to receive my weekly blogs in your email.